Cabrera vs. Reyes

[crazybob60]

Who would you rather have for the rest of this season only??? Miguel Cabrera or Jose Reyes?

[Jivedude]

Not sure, but fortunately I have both of them so I don't have to worry about that.

[Phatjimmy]

very tough to say. From what I've heard, the Marlins will want to give Cabrera plenty of chances to play as much as possible, and that the Mets might have Reyes on a much shorter leash if Reyes starts to struggle.

Also, Miguel might have a shot to play a couple positions, if Lowell gets traded. Whereas Reyes will only see time at SS.

If I was in a keeper league, though, I would rather have Reyes.

[Arlo]

Agreed with Phatjimmy - if you need to make a decision now for this season, the most likely playing time scenarios favor Cabrera.