M Cab's Value Now

[rotterdam_82]

I think he's gonna struggle to get those 100 runs and Rbi's that you're all talking about as a lock. He'll be lucky to go 90/90 even with 30+ dingers.

The Marlins have nobody to protect him. And when I say nobody I mean exactly that. I'm struggling to put a lineup together......

[Yoda]

How many .320 35 105 100 3 guys are in the top 10?

Here are some pretty rough projections, in no particular order, for some guys. So "if" Cabrera put up the #'s posted above, where would he fall? I can't see him being top 5 or 6 like he was before the fire/sale.

Redraft league only.

Pujols .330 42 125 125 10
Arod .300 45 125 125 15
Vlad .320 35 115 115 15
Manny .310 45 130 105 1
Ortiz .300 45 130 110 1
Teix .300 45 130 110 3
Santana -
Soriano .275 35 100 100 30
Tejada .305 28 115 100 5
Abreu .300 25 100 105 25
Bay .300 33 105 110 15
Sheffield .295 35 125 105 8
Crawford .300 18 80 105 45
Ichiro .315 15 70 115 30
Wright .310 30 110 105 17

How many of these guys will be 23 in 06, well before their peak? How many players qualify at OF, 3B?

[J35J]

How many .320 35 105 100 3 guys are in the top 10?

Here are some pretty rough projections, in no particular order, for some guys. So "if" Cabrera put up the #'s posted above, where would he fall? I can't see him being top 5 or 6 like he was before the fire/sale.

Redraft league only.

Pujols .330 42 125 125 10
Arod .300 45 125 125 15
Vlad .320 35 115 115 15
Manny .310 45 130 105 1
Ortiz .300 45 130 110 1
Teix .300 45 130 110 3
Santana -
Soriano .275 35 100 100 30
Tejada .305 28 115 100 5
Abreu .300 25 100 105 25
Bay .300 33 105 110 15
Sheffield .295 35 125 105 8
Crawford .300 18 80 105 45
Ichiro .315 15 70 115 30
Wright .310 30 110 105 17

How many of these guys will be 23 in 06, well before their peak? How many players qualify at OF, 3B?

I agree with you for a "keeper" league but I'm talking redraft!

[Yoda]

How many .320 35 105 100 3 guys are in the top 10?

Here are some pretty rough projections, in no particular order, for some guys. So "if" Cabrera put up the #'s posted above, where would he fall? I can't see him being top 5 or 6 like he was before the fire/sale.

Redraft league only.

Pujols .330 42 125 125 10
Arod .300 45 125 125 15
Vlad .320 35 115 115 15
Manny .310 45 130 105 1
Ortiz .300 45 130 110 1
Teix .300 45 130 110 3
Santana -
Soriano .275 35 100 100 30
Tejada .305 28 115 100 5
Abreu .300 25 100 105 25
Bay .300 33 105 110 15
Sheffield .295 35 125 105 8
Crawford .300 18 80 105 45
Ichiro .315 15 70 115 30
Wright .310 30 110 105 17

How many of these guys will be 23 in 06, well before their peak? How many players qualify at OF, 3B?

I agree with you for a "keeper" league but I'm talking redraft!

I'm talking redraft. Look, when I see him not live upto expectations then I will change my position. He has done nothing but exceed most people's expectations thus far. He is in his prepeak and if his current progression continues, you would be crazy to downgrade him for any reason other than injuries.

You guys can all downgrade him if you want. I still have him as my top 5 going into the draft unless he gets hurt. That is all I have to say in this thread.

[hyacinth]

I'm talking redraft. Look, when I see him not live upto expectations then I will change my position. He has done nothing but exceed most people's expectations thus far. He is in his prepeak and if his current progression continues, you would be crazy to downgrade him for any reason other than injuries.

You guys can all downgrade him if you want. I still have him as my top 5 going into the draft unless he gets hurt. That is all I have to say in this thread.

I wonder if Miguel Cabrera is reading this right now and going "AMEN Yoda!".

[J35J]

I'm talking redraft. Look, when I see him not live upto expectations then I will change my position. He has done nothing but exceed most people's expectations thus far. He is in his prepeak and if his current progression continues, you would be crazy to downgrade him for any reason other than injuries.

You guys can all downgrade him if you want. I still have him as my top 5 going into the draft unless he gets hurt. That is all I have to say in this thread.

I wonder if Miguel Cabrera is reading this right now and going "AMEN Yoda!".

I wonder if Yoda IS Miguel Cabrera.....

[Yoda]

I'm talking redraft. Look, when I see him not live upto expectations then I will change my position. He has done nothing but exceed most people's expectations thus far. He is in his prepeak and if his current progression continues, you would be crazy to downgrade him for any reason other than injuries.

You guys can all downgrade him if you want. I still have him as my top 5 going into the draft unless he gets hurt. That is all I have to say in this thread.

I wonder if Miguel Cabrera is reading this right now and going "AMEN Yoda!".

I am your father...



I wonder if Yoda IS Miguel Cabrera.....

[The Cow]

WHat I meant to say was that a #3 pick with 100 RBIs is worth less than a #3 pick with 120 RBIs. Now do the math it will make sense. I shouldn't have skipped typing class. Also just because Miggy is 23 does not mean his numbers will improve, but thats a whole nother argument.

[Yoda]

Miggy won't hit 40... I'm disappointed and shocked.