Bartolo Colon - AL Cy Young

[RynMan]

Voters = idiots.

And to all those A's fan's who think their rotation is better than the Angels

[CubsFan7724]

The people who voted Rivera over Santana should have their voting privileges revoked. Unless you are nearly Gagne dominant as a closer, you shouldn't even be coming close to a Cy Young.

[BritSox]

Does know where to find RS stats?

I need 'em for Santana, Colon, Millwood, Buehrle and Garland.

[kimchi_chigae]

Does know where to find RS stats?

I need 'em for Santana, Colon, Millwood, Buehrle and Garland.

one can find them on ESPN

ESPN RS

Santana - 4.70
Colon - 6.02
Millwood - 3.98
Buehrle - 4.15
Garland - 5.29

[NY Yankees Fan 2004]

Definately not happy with this Colon had a great year, but Cy Young Calliber- definately not

[RynMan]

I had an argument with a friend of mine yesterday about this. He said Colon deserved it over Santana because he was on a contender and that he had 20+ wins. My argument was that it's not Santana's fault that he does not have the contextual luxury that Colon does (run support, very good bullpen, strong offense).

Not sure how you can argue that one guy was the best pitcher in the league when the only stat he was better than another pitcher in, is a statistic that is terrible at evaluating his individual performance.