I think Reyes is too high. I'd be surprised if he ever becomes more than a Scott Podsednik +10 HR. He doesn't drive in many runs, and he won't score tons of runs because he doesn't take a base on balls and I don't expect that to change much. I'd rather have Young and Felix and if I had to look around a little bit I'm sure I could find a couple more guys I'd put in front of him.
Maybe Carlos Zambrano, Aramis Ramirez, Chase Utley, or Grady Sizemore.