I'm in a Yahoo weekly H2H playoff matchup, and while there's still a way to go, it's becoming increasingly likely that strikeouts (pitching) could determine who wins the matchup. My question is, do you think it's OK to drop your catcher on Saturday in order to pick up a pitcher starting on the Sunday? It's a 10-team league, and my catcher is Jason Kendall, so in terms of value I don't think I'm really hurting myself, since pretty similar guys are available as free agents and I could pick one of them up after the Sunday. Also, I don't think it would affect any of the hitting categories, and I would only consider doing it if we're within 5-10 Ks of each other after Saturday. Would you have a problem ethically if someone else did it in your league? Thanks.
I'd say go ahead, its not like you have a stud VMart or Varitek catcher and someone will pick him up so why not do it, plus Im sure some WW guys in a 10 team league are much better than Kendall anyway. And I don't see anything wrong with ethics here.
Red Stripe wrote:I'd say go ahead, its not like you have a stud VMart or Varitek catcher and someone will pick him up so why not do it, plus Im sure some WW guys in a 10 team league are much better than Kendall anyway. And I don't see anything wrong with ethics here.
agreed thats just good strategy
Hot Chick Draft: 1.01: Scarlett Johansson 2.12: Mila Kunis 3.01: Malin Akerman 4.12: Britney Spears 5.01: Jessica Simpson 6.12: Penelope Cruz 7.01: Tera Patrick 8.12: Christina Milian 9.01: Cameron Diaz 10.12: Lucy Liu 11.1: Jamie Lynn Sigler
I'd do it, especially if Kendall catches saturday night which makes it unlikely he will catch the sunday afternoon game. I see nothing wrong with not starting a catcher. Its your roster-use it as creatively as you like.
You have to start somebody at every position . I realize Yahoo doesn't force you to, but it has been the basic rules of fantasy baseball since its inception ..
As long as I've been playing, there have been some people that bench all of their starters for a given week in an effort to win ERA and WHIP. If it's ok to bench starters, I don't think it's wrong to bench a catcher. On the other hand, it does kind of go against the spirit of the game and if I lost in the playoffs because of it, I'd be pretty pissed.
Tough call. I'd say go with your gut. I'm honestly not sure what I would do in this situation.
There are plenty of times that I leave position players or pitchers on the bench. Today, King Felix vs. Texas as an example. Last week I dumped my only SS so I could pick-up a FA spot SP for a day. Dumped the FA spot SP the next day and picked up FA Counsel. I think anyone who has a problem with you having a vacant roster slot, has more serious problems in their personal lives.
bselig wrote:Of course do it if it is going to help your team...you don't have to start someone at every position and for anybody to even suggest that is pure inanity. Make the roster move.
I'd qualify this: I don't think running a whole season with the 'no catcher strategy' is acceptable, for instance, as you really should have someone for every position. Doing it for one day, in a really tight h2h race, is imho a different matter. I mean, you'd drop your ace on the last day if it were the only way of winning, wouldn't you?
Hall of Fame Hero
Joined: 5 Mar 2005
Home Cafe: Baseball
Location: You don't care, do you? No... because you're unconscious.