I don't know that he was a sleeper, exactly, but Octavio Dotel hurt me something awful. Juan Cruz wasn't the pitcher I was hoping for, either.
But, like the poster above, this was a year in which I was mostly dead on in my predictions. People laughed at my pitching staff, saying that I couldn't possibly place - Pedro would get hurt, Dontrelle isn't very good to begin with, Reitsma was a stupid pick, etc. And my offense. Man, people made fun of my Barmes/Lugo combo in a 14 teamer.
Mota was a huge disappointment in that I kept him over Carpenter because I only had 1 other closer. Kyle Lohse, what an arm, but what a moron, Kahil, maybe if he could ever stay healthy, I also predicted that Werth would have a decent year, Crede would break out of his funk and produce, and that A. Nunez with a starting spot would be able to produce in KC, not so, not so.