chipper or luis

[jmintert]

Who do you think is better for a head-to-head league where scoring is

1b 1 point
2b 2
3b 3
hr 6
r 1
rbi 1
sb 1
cs -1
w 1
k -1

Chipper or Luis Gonzo. I have Chipper but am worried about his nagging injuries and lack of HR power. However, Gonzo's on a crappy team this year, which hurts the rbi opportunity. Overall YTD, Gonzo in my league has about 30 points on Chipper, something like 220 YTD points v. 190 for chipper. Thoughts on remaining production comparisons?

[trevisc]

I like Chipper over Gonzo

[CaptainJenks]

i would go with gonzo, i like jones but he is in the best hitting lineup and he still has under 40rbi, and he is batting like #4 or five

[Guest]

GONZO

[phunkadelic]

It just my opinion, but I think the disparity in points between Gonzo and Chipper is going to get much larger.

Gonzo's really, really good. Chipper is not a whole lot better than an average OF and never will be. Now if starts playing 3B again, it's a different story.

[Jockpunk]

I have both on my team and prefer gonzo.

that being said, i dont know how anyone can say chipper is just an average outfielder. He had a few years with 40+ hrs and has hit .315+ a number of times. I do agree that his best days may be past though.

[HOOTIE]

[quote

Gonzo's really, really good. Chipper is not a whole lot better than an average OF and never will be. Now if starts playing 3B again, it's a different story.[/quote]

Better look again. Chippers career ops is .948. I doubt you can find 10 outfielders higher. I doubt you find 20 guys any position career wise better.