Red Socks or Pin Stripes

[eftda]

Also Gibson in 68, Mcclain in 68, Fingers in 81, Hernandez in 84, and (I can't believe I forgot him) Eck in 92.

They didn't win it the same year that they won the Cy Young.

[pokerplaya]

The HoF chooses the uniform and IMO that makes it pretty obvious (Yankees) and I think it's the right choice. The Astros and Blue Jays aren't really options and you can make an argument for the Red Sox since he spent the majority of his career in Boston. The rings came in NY though and I think that is what they will look at.

I feel the same way. Ever since MLB took control over what team an inductee goes in under, I'd think it's going to be the Yankees. Although, Carter went in as an Expo despite having his most notorious days as a Met.

[pokerplaya]

Another question: Piazza...HOF as a Dodger or Met?

[Amazinz]

Good point about Carter although my opinion is that that had more to do with no Expos in the HoF and the Expos becoming the Nationals.

[davidmarver]

Dodger.

[da1chipo]

Another question: Piazza...HOF as a Dodger or Met?

I'm hoping "visitor."

[pokerplaya]

Good point about Carter although my opinion is that that had more to do with no Expos in the HoF and the Expos becoming the Nationals.

Yeah, that does make a lot of sense.

[Amazinz]

Piazza is guaranteed to go into the hall as a Met. Any other opinion is just California Dreamin'.

[pokerplaya]

Another question: Piazza...HOF as a Dodger or Met?

I'm hoping "visitor."

Doubtful.

[blankman]

Piazza is guaranteed to go into the hall as a Met. Any other opinion is just California Dreamin'.

Agreed. When I hear the name Piazza, I think of the Mets.