Halladay this good?

[Brownie]

How good is Roy Halladay? Will he continue winning at this pace? Will his second have be more of the same? Is he worth trading a notch closer (Wagner) for?

[tjhksig]

Halladay was 19-5 last year, he'll do better this year (W wise). If you have other closers to get you saves, I'd do it.

You can't win 9 in a row on luck. You gots to be good.

On the other hand, avoid Cory Lidle.

[Madison]

Halladay is pitching well, and when he doesn't he's still got that great lineup to help.

[chiuondis]

halladay is on fire.... just like delgado...

[DGroundhog]

Halladay for Wagner could be a good deal for both sides. Both are studs at their positions. If you need SP and think you can afford to trade a RP like Wagner for Halladay, that is a good move.

It really ddepends on what your team needs, and your roto standings if you are in a roto league. It is certainly fair.

[Nomar4prez]

I believe toronto is going to a 4-man rotation. If this happens, it could be good for Halladay short-term, but near the end of the season, I would expect the fatigue to wear on him.

[The Jury]

Echo Nomar's sentiments.

[Transmogrifier]

Toronto has already dropped the four man rotation; check out some of Neyer's columns on this. Lidle and others were a little peaved.

I bet they'll do a modified four man rotation...

I think Halladay's arm will be fine. Remember, Riccardi comes from the Beane system where they take Damn good care of their pitchers.

[jury duty]

yeah, if you can spare a closer, wagner for halladay would be a good deal.

[Nero]

Yep...Toronto has shevled the 4man idea...look at the way Escobar is pitching

secondly...Halladay IS this good...his K to BB ratio is 46-6 over his 9 game streak and his era is under 3 with the exception of the 7 run blow up against Boston