wondering whom you guys would rate, and how you would rate the top 15 pitchers for a keeper, that is, for the rest of this season and the next season for the most part. here are some names to consider but i have no list
and anyone else i forgot. just wanted to see how you rank these guys.
Peavy, Harden, Halladay, Carpenter based on how they were drafted (make great keeper value).
I may even throw a few guys that would have gone undrafted in there such as Duke, Garland (though he is unlikely to repeat...at least in my eyes), Chacin, and several others since they'd bring great value.
Owalt, Peavy, Prior, Santana, Harden, Carpenter, Halladay, Pedro, , Buerhle, Sheets, Willis, AJ, Beckett, Bonderman, C. Zambrano are my top 15.
That's not necessarily saying that they'll have the 15 best years next year, but have the higher probability than most other pitchers such as aging pitchers like RJ, Schilling and Clemens. RJ & Schilling are battling injuries and Clemens already retired once, so who knows if he'll retire again.
might be....kind of grey area as it is just a question regarding ranking players. something often found in here. aside from that, please assume clemens WILL return for ranking purposes, and could anyone DARE rank their top fifteen 1-15?