Joel Zumaya or Philip Humber

[PlayingWithFire]

Which one would you rather have in a dynasty league with standard setting.(h2h, and standard categories)

[raiders_umpire]

there are a bunch more players i would rather have than those 2..... if i had to choose one, i guess i would take zumaya,,,,, with humbers surgery,,, you just never know how he will come back... zumaya was solid in AA earlier this year,,, he has struggled in AAA but considering his age,,, i am not going to hold it against him, but maybe he can it going again....

[mcqfesijiba]

Out of those two, Zumaya for sure. He's closer to the big leagues, and as the previous poster mentioned Humber has undergone Tommy John surgery and will be out for quite a while.

Just to counter one thing the previous poster said, Zumaya has really only had one bad start out of three in AAA. His overall numbers don't look great, but that was mostly his first start, which was pretty bad. Still, 3 starts in AAA is a very small sample size.

[Jenkins]

Zumaya all the way. That guy is incredible. I am in a dynasty league, and I cant wait for that guy to be offered. He is definitely my first round draft pick next year.