Gagne or Smoltz

[twinsfan]

In a 10 team 5x5 H2H league, who would you rather have?

[quickfingerz]

By seasons end:
Wins: EVEN (this is more luck than anything really)
Saves: Smoltz +5
ERA: Smoltz: +1.00
WHIP: Gagne: +0.35
K's: Gagne: +0.75K per IP

I like Gagne because he dominates WHIP and K's much more than Smoltz wins in saves and ERA.