Anthony Reyes Vs. Brandon Mccarthy

[Jenkins]

Who would you rather have in a dynasty league?

[hybrid]

For me it's McCarthy, I think he is a better prospect and Reyes (though he is indeed a good prospect) scares me to much with his constant injuries. I'm afraid he will never hold up over a 162 MLB season, since he has had trouble in college and the minors.

[Jenkins]

Thats about what I was thinking. Mccarthy just looked rough in his MLB outings thus far even though he is only 21. Would you drop Mccarthy for Scott Baker??