Well if you saw my team it wouldn't look that ridiculous. Let's just say I already had A-Rod, Beltran, Crawford, and Kent, and acquired Tejada via a trade. And I really needed one more solid SP, Peavy was exactly what I needed. And I'm still winning saves without Izzy. Plus I've dominated the league since week 2 so I have a little room to fool around.
All things being equal, I'll admit I "lost" the trade in terms of pure player value but in terms of boosting my team's points, I may have made the right move, especially if Beltre keeps hitting at the level he should be.