I went with David Ortiz. Yes, I'm a little biased as a Red Sox Fan, but you can't dispute his #'s and how clutch this guy truley is. I think Manny deserves to be on this list. Don't see how you have Michael Young as one of the Canidates
Maybe you meant Sori?
Well I just threw him in there, thought he deserved it...here are his numbers:
batting .324, 12 homers, 43 RBIs, 58 Runs, and 2nd in the AL with 107 hits.
Also he has just 4 errors.
I dunno, maybe he doesnt deserve to be on the list...