NYMetsGM wrote:Who will have the better career?
Who can know that?
Personally, I'll gamble on the hitter over the pitcher purely on the basis of how often pitchers seem to get hurt nowadays.
Obviously, for 2005, I think Davies is the better option, and probably for 2006 as well as he should be in their rotation for good whereas while I think Hermida might make the opening day roster, he might be a mid-season call-up and might struggle, as rookies often do.
For 2007 and beyond, I'd gamble on Hermida.