what about Edwin ENCARNACION

[Members Only Jackets]

should i drop Ian Kinsler or ian Stewart (long way to go apparently) for Edwin ENCARNACION? Rotoworld says he's waiting for the Reds to trade Randa...after that he'll get THE CALL!


Should i?

[bigken117]

well I woudln't drop Stewart...dropping Kinsler depends on your needs at 3B I guess. I like Kinsler more myself.

[King Tim]

I am very high on Edwin. The power is starting to develop and playing in Cincy won't hurt the #s either. I'd grab him but wouldn't give up Stewart.

[hybrid]

I think it more depends on if you want a 3B next year in Encarnacion or Kinsler who possibly will be at 2B next year (if they move Soriano). Personally I like Edwin and his potential more as I'm not entirely sold on Kinsler. I saw a good amount of Edwin during ST and surprised me with how good he looked at the plate. Because before then I didn't think much of him by just reading about him, but after seeing him I thought he could have possibly a break out year ... which he pretty much is right now.