Best 3b option.

[davidmarver]

Looking for someone to rank these eligible 3b (or at least choose the top few):

Joe Randa, Ryan Freel, Rob Mackowiak, Eric Hinske, Olmedo Saenz, Jorge Cantu, Nick Green, Chad Tracy, Michael Cuddyer, Joe Crede, Aaron Boone.

[Drunken Rhino]

I'd say:

Hinske (he was the AL ROY 3 years ago...)
Freel
Cuddyer
Mackowiak
Randa

Crap

[yanks#27]

When given the time, Freel has been awesome.
Hinske is great, D-wise horrible, and his last 2 seasons weren't exactly memorable.
Randa has shown to be a consistent .280+ hitter.
Tracy was okay last year, not enough pop.
Cantu has a good future ahead.
As well as Crede.