M gonz or Rincon

[Rowand]

who will put up better numbers and will mesa be traded?

[fiz]

id go with gonzo - there's a chance he'll be the closer and tha's not really the case with rincon

[Trot Nixon]

who will put up better numbers and will mesa be traded?

I'd go with Gonzo, But Mesa being traded has been a topic of much discussion here and most people on the boards think that he won't be traded by the end of the year. I'm hoping the board is wrong and he does get traded but its not likely. A guy can dream can't he???

[TB13]

I say Rincon. Gonzo is not putting up the unhittable #'s of last year. Rincon continues to be nothing but solid.

[thehat]

Rincon by an eyelash on longer term success. But this is so close it's basically just a tossup.

[RugbyD]

Rincon for the Ws he should be racking up over the year.

[go_jays_go]

Rincon for the Ws he should be racking up over the year.

Gonzalez.

Rincon took steroids

[NY Yankees Fan 2004]

I say Rincon. Gonzo is not putting up the unhittable #'s of last year. Rincon continues to be nothing but solid.

have to disagree here. I have both of these guys on my team. Gonzo has been solid for the most part.. He had 2 big implosions in the beginning of the year and had one recently in a meaningless situation (they were up 10-3).

Rincon hasnt been that great lately and has been worse than Gonzo.. Just the threat of Gonzo getting saves later in the year makes him more valuable..