Who are the top 3-5 hitters and pitchers??

[reznorsboy]

I would add D. Lee to the list

[9er Fan]

Here's my (pretty quick) take, assuming this year only.

Batters:
Pujols
A-Rod
Abreu
Tejada

SP:
Santana
Peavy
Pedro
Prior

Batters
RP:
Rivera
Nathan
K-Rod
Lidge

What about B Roberts

What the poster is really asking is when you look at the whole season (when all is said and done), who will have the best stats (at least that's what I based my list on); IMO Roberts won't make the top 3-5.

[Kingctb27]

Pujols
A-Rod
Vlad
Beltran
Tejada

Santana
Prior
Peavy
Halladay
Schmidt

Lidge
K-Rod
Nathen
Gagne
Rivera

[Victor]

Hitters:
Pujols
Arod
Tejada
Abreu
Vlad

Pitchers:
Santana
Prior
Pedro
Halladay
Peavy

RP:
Rivera (I wouldn't doubt him, and I hate the Yankees)
Lidge
KRod
Nathan
F Cordero

[The Guru]

Hitters:
1 - Arod
2 - Vlad
3 - Tejada
4 - Pujois
5 - Manny

Starting Pitchers:
1 - Santana
2 - Myers
3 - Peavy
4 - Clemens
5 - Beckett

Relief Pitchers:
1 - Nathan
2 - K-Rod
3 - Riverar
4 - Hoffman
5 - BJ Ryan

[beltrans_boy]

Hitters:
1 - Pujols
2 - Vlad
3 - ARod
4 - Abreu
5 - Tejada

Pitchers:
1 - Pedro
2 - Prior
3 - Santana
4 - Beckett
5 - Halladay

[The Guru]

I don't think Halladay will be a top 5 pitcher this year because he has 3 of the top offenses in MLB in his division.

Baltimore
Boston
Yankees

Thoses offenses are just too good that his stats will not be that great.

[beltrans_boy]

I don't think Halladay will be a top 5 pitcher this year because he has 3 of the top offenses in MLB in his division.

Baltimore
Boston
Yankees

Thoses offenses are just too good that his stats will not be that great.

He was pretty good 2 years ago. He was injured last year. I see no reason why he won't revert to his 2003 form. And as of right now, name somebody better that's not already on my list...

[davidmarver]

Hitters:
1 - Pujols
2 - Vlad
3 - ARod
4 - Abreu
5 - Tejada

Pitchers:
1 - Pedro
2 - Prior
3 - Santana
4 - Beckett
5 - Halladay

No Clemens, no Peavy?

[beltrans_boy]

Hitters:
1 - Pujols
2 - Vlad
3 - ARod
4 - Abreu
5 - Tejada

Pitchers:
1 - Pedro
2 - Prior
3 - Santana
4 - Beckett
5 - Halladay

No Clemens, no Peavy?

Peavy was the only one I struggled with over Halladay. I'm not questioning Peavy's abilities, but I'd like to see him put up his '04 and '05 numbers over the course of an entire big league season before I put him up there with those 4. Clemens, in my humble opinion, is going to be outside the top 10 for the remainder of the season (especially with the injury he sustained today).