This year I am playing in two free head to head leagues where I used the opposite strategy. Both leagues have extensive cats, one being 9x9 and the other being 7x7. In one league I attempted to punt SP, while in the other league I attempted to punt RP.
In the 7x7 12 team league I didn't draft a closer, or even a RP, until round 15 with B. Donnelly. Then I took Mike Gonzalez (17), Scot Linebrink (19), and Joe Borowski (22). My SP staff has been decent, with RJ, Peavy, Moose, and Livan Hernandez anchoring the staff. I felt my hitters were dominant coming out of the draft, but have several slumping guys (Helton, Renteria, Blalock, Carlos Lee, Sexson, Andruw Jones). With those players coming around nicely I am not too worried about it. The crazy thing about this league is that I consistantly win the saves category since I was quick to pick up any emerging RP. My original MR were dropped and replaced by people like Yhency Brazoban, B. Lyon, Turnbow, and even guys like T. Jones. This strategy I felt worked out very well and I was amazed by the number of closers available in a 12 person league. In this league I am 6 of 12.
In the 12 team 9x9 league I focused on getting the elite to semi-elite RP and trying to pick up a couple of high K pitchers who were cheap. I got K-rod (3), Foulke (4), BJ Ryan (8), along with some lesser guys like Chad Cordero and Mike Adams. Also grabbed some top MR in Tom Gordon and Mike Gonzalez. My SP were AJ Burnett and Kelvim Escobar, with a side of Jeff Weaver and John Thomson. In this league I thought my hitting was again steady (Jeter, Beltre, Edmonds, Carlos Lee, Derek Lee, and A. Jones) but if it weren't for Roberts, I would probably lose a bunch of hitting cats. This league is the more competitive of the 2 and I am in 4th place. (Every team but 2 has at least 5 transactions, pretty good for a free yahoo league)
Looking back, even though I am in 6th place in the SP draft, I feel much more confident about that team. A couple of struggling stars can mean all the difference and last week I went 12-2, the week before 9-5. I learned that there are always saves on the waiver wire. Even my RP draft I was able to add B. Myers who helps me compete in Ks. Another lesson is to be quick to the wire early in the season. You don't want to miss the next B. Myers or Turnbow. in general I found that my pitching defeciencies were pretty easy to pick up off the wire. Yet another reason to go hitting heavy in the draft.
I think my problems in all 4 leagues have been my main source for the projections. I used to average a bunch of sources (last year 5, the year beofre that 6) and this year I limited it to only two sources, with a heavy reliance on Ron Shandler's Forecaster. I must say that all of my hitters have underperformed from his, and my, expectations.