*Second Baseman Rankings*

[CB4MiamiHeat]

soriano
roberts
kent
giles
loretta
reyes
barnes
boone

[FlawedReasoning]

soriano
roberts
kent
giles
loretta
reyes
barnes
boone

Two things:

1) For the love of god spell his name right (barMes). He's not a bookstore.

and 2) Put him above Reyes. Seriously.

[CB4MiamiHeat]

the thing is i think Reyes can get 35-40 SB's and IMO Barmes has been on a tear but he wont keep this up.So i have Reyes in front just because of the SB's since theyre hard to come by.

WHats your list?

[cookman]

davidmarver, just about every post I see from you, you're talking up someone on the Padres. Big Pads fan, huh?

[FlawedReasoning]

the thing is i think Reyes can get 35-40 SB's and IMO Barmes has been on a tear but he wont keep this up.So i have Reyes in front just because of the SB's since theyre hard to come by.

WHats your list?

Something pretty close to yours, I think...

soriano
roberts
kent
barmes
loretta
vidro
reyes
iguchi
figgins
boone
giles


I'm not very big on Giles or Boone, but I know other people are. Also Figgins is sort of a wild card--it's hard to know how much playing time he'll get.

And like you said, it might just be that I buy into Barmes. I do think he's for real (that could be because I'm a Barmes owner... it seems the believer/non-believer split runs pretty neatly down the divide between owner/non-owner). But if you think this is just a phase, then I could see how that would seriously change his ranking. I also buy into Roberts, too, even though I don't own him. So it might just be that I'm a sucker for the hot streak.

EDIT: Oh yeah, and Utley in there somewhere. Hard to keep all of them straight.

[davidmarver]

davidmarver, just about every post I see from you, you're talking up someone on the Padres. Big Pads fan, huh?

Well, I'd rather speak about things I know than those I do not. I'm a huge Padres fan, but I watch most West-Coast baseball, not just the Padres.

(Closet A's fan...they're my AL team).

[Eastern Lightning]

No love for Utley?

[baseballnewb]

Soriano
Roberts
Kent
Giles


After that its too hard to judge. Will reyes stay healthy, will loretta repeat last years avg (doubtful), power(not likely at all), will he keep stealing(doubltful again). Is Boone done? Is Barmes just a coor's field hitter which lowers his value in head to head. Etc.

[Laean]

davidmarver, just about every post I see from you, you're talking up someone on the Padres. Big Pads fan, huh?

Well, I'd rather speak about things I know than those I do not. I'm a huge Padres fan, but I watch most West-Coast baseball, not just the Padres.

(Closet A's fan...they're my AL team).

i'm a padres and angels fan.

anyway, how come no love for biggio? isn't he almost on par with vidro?

100 170 20 70 10 .290 seems very reachable to me.

[Danimal]

I'd love to have Roberts right now, but I think he'll come back down to earth and Utley will rise above. Might take a year, but ...