Cantu or Castillo

[daveblotto]

I have J.Vidro as my main 2B but I've been playing Both him and Cantu (one in Util spot) to try to make up for some Struggeling OF players BA(like A.Rowand). For the long haul is Castillo going To be better than Cantu? Thank

[nikku88]

I'm sure you can find a better player for the Util pos. than either Cantu or Castillo unless it's a 20 team league or something.
I like Castillo more though.

[d18Mike]

Think about Utley or Polanco ... they may be on your WW as they are now job-sharing in PHIL. That's untenable. And Cubs have expressed some interest in Poloanco.

If Poloanco is moved, the value of both soar and would be far better options than Cantu or Castillo.

[daveblotto]

Polanco is avail. Nikku, I do have better options for the long haul, I have Kearns, Bonds, Rowand, Finley and R.Sanders. I've been taking a Beating in BA and I Just decided to go with the guys who have been hitting the most. Cantu has been cooling now, and He may never do anything the rest of the year. This is only for Depth. Not a necceseity by Any means. Thanks to all-DBA

[slomo007]

I'd take Castillo by a wide margin.

[stumpak]

I think Castillo is typically very overrated, but I would be much much more comfortable with him than Cantu.

[Paco625]

I'd take Castillo by a wide margin.

me too, not even a question. Castillo wont get as many HRs but will hit for a better average, score more runs, and steal a few bases.