rowand or bay

[Ntjean]

Rowand or Bay? Whos the better guy to have on my team right now...

its a 5x5 keeper league with 5 keepers

heres my rosterThis is a regular scoring 5x5 yahoo league but it is a keeper league as well

C: R. Hernandez
1B: David Ortiz
2B: A. Soriano
3B. Melvin Mora
SS: Chone Figgins
OF: pedro feliz
OF: aaron Rowand
OF Larry Walker
Util:Luis Gonzalez
BN. jason bay
BN: willy mo pena

SP: Carlos Zambrano
SP: Roy Halladay
RP: Jason Isringhausen
RP: S. Takatsu
P: Zito
P: Bartolo Colon
P: Jose Mesa
BN: Andy Petitte
BN: V. Zambrano
Bn: Kenny Rogers


We are in a regular Yahoo roto league but with a 1500 max inning pitched.

[orangecrushv]

I'd keep Bay. I've seen Rowland dropped recently.

-Rich

[baseballrich]

Rowand is the guy to keep. He has more potential in more catagories than Bay. Don't forget it is April. My rule of thumb is to not look at performance until at least May 15th. 15 day slumps in July will not make you drop a potential above average player

[jazzfunk2]

Bay and by a wide margin. Bay has just started to find his groove (he's 3-3 , with an RBI as of this post). Provided he stays somewhat healthy, Bay will have weeks where he carries your offense all by himself. His production for my team last summer kept my hopes up while the rest of my team underperformed.

Rowand is not bad, but I group him in with the mid-range outfield crop, Floyd, J. Jones, Cameron, Sanders - all solid, 3-4 category players. Bay can light it up.

[WebHamster]

This thread has been eaten by the Webhamster. This typically happens to solitary posts that move too far away from their own kind. Please repost your question or issue in the appropriate forum where it can dwell among the herd of similar threads and where the mods will bravely protect it from the mean rodents. And please ... do not feed the Webhamster! Thank you.