Looper or Jimenez??? Who should I take?

[DaveClay12]

I'm trading Paul Konerko and Keith Foulke for Jeff Bagwell and either Jose Jimenez or Braden Looper? Who would you suggest I take?

Pretty much normal, weekly 6x6 roto league... Here's my roster:

C: Mike Piazza
1b: Erubiel Durazo
2b: Roberto Alomar
3b: Joe Crede
SS: Orlando Cabrera
OF: Shawn Green
OF: Vernon Wells
OF: Shannon Stewart
Util: Corey Patterson
Bench: Trot Nixon, Paul Konerko, D'Angelo Jimenez, David Segui

SP: Barry Zito
SP: Mark Prior
SP: Mark Buehrle
SP: Tony Armas, Jr.
SP: Kip Wells

RP: Keith Foulke
RP: Lance Carter
RP: Damaso Marte
Bench: Francisco Cordero, Brandon Duckworth, Joe Kennedy, Ricardo Rodriguez, Joe Nathan, Kelvim Escobar

Farm: Jose Reyes-SS-NYM, Prince Fielder -1B-Cle, John-Ford Griffin-OF-Tor(?), Ben Kozlowski-P-Tex

[Sponge]

Jimenez will get you more saves.

[kentx12]

Jiminez

[jdh]

Take Jimenez. He had 41 saves last year, although his ERA may hurt you a bit, given that he pitches at Coors. Last year, he had like a 2.90 ERA at Coors, so maybe it doesn't affect him that much. MacKeon, Florida's new manager, is known for not really believing in the traditional use of the closer, and likes the committee approach, meaning that Looper will likely start losing saves.

[Giants Rule]

Jimenez.