Reliever Comparison - Madson or Calero?

[KolbSaves]

I think Street would get a crack first. It's not like Kikkoman is a wiley vet or anything.

[ravenmad22]

I think Street would get a crack first. It's not like Kikkoman is a wiley vet or anything.

Calero's been around. Street is the future closer, but I bet Calero would take over as he has 3 years experience and rookies don't generally close in the MLB.

[LBJackal]

Calero's a lot better. For wins, maybe Madson has the edge because he's not the primary setup man and pitches in games where they're losing/tied more often, but I'd take Calero over him still.

Isn't Tim Worrell the primary set up man?

Kiko should close if Dotel gets traded too. All signs point to Mr. Soy Sauce.

I know, I said Madson has the edge in wins because he's NOT the primary setup man.

And also... I'd say Calero would get first crack at closing. As of now, he's a lot better. If this is September and they're out of the race, maybe Street. But Calero has been pretty good throughout his career.

[RynMan]

Madson.....I mean Calero.

[wrveres]

Kiko