Who will win the battle of the "Smashed by Minor Leaguers"?

[intense]

Who will have a more impressing 1st start back from injury... Prior or Schilling...? As a cubs fan...but a Schilling owner it's hard for me to pick one, but I think Schilling will have a better outting, what do all of you think?

I predict

Schilling with 7 IP... 6 hits, 2 ER, 7Ks and a W

Prior 6 IP... 7 hits, 3 ER, 8Ks and a no decision.

[WharfRat]

Ha, nice title....What I HOPE will happen is Schilling gets bombed hard and has to be dragged from the field weeping like a punk.

But what I think will happen...is something similar to what you posted. Tough to say though, since who knows how accurate their performances against minor leaguers probably were. It wouldn't surprise me if they both went out and pitched 6 innings with 2 ER. Or, they could get blown up.

[BritSox]

As a Red Sox fan and Prior owner, i'm rooting for both, but i think Prior is the more likely to have a good start... though Schilling could get hit for a few and still get the W as he is up against Jaret Wright.

[Rkiivs]

Talk about mixed emotions.

I want Schilling to blow it out (he's on my fantasy team) but he's pitching against my Yanks.

Time to head to the ARGH! GRR! thread.