Keeper League Questions

[Sir Cheese]

I just visited this site; it seems like you guys could help me out with a keeper question I have...

I'm in an 18 Team League that keeps 8 players
It is a normal 5x5 league with HOLDs added.

I need some help choosing who to keep.

The players I'm considering:

Cliff Floyd
Jorge Posada
Roberto Alomar
Jamie Moyer
Mariano Rivera
K. Ishii
Jose Mesa
Juan Gonzalez
Arthur Rhodes <-- FOR HOLDS
Randy Winn

I'd appreciate any help I could get. Thanks


Oh... and if someone finds another free keeper league... please tell me. I'd really like to find one.


THANKS

[HOOTIE]

You listed 10 guys, need 2 to cut. There are only 3 cuttables imo. Winn/Rhodes/or Ishii. Even if you cut Rhodes, you should be able to find other hold guys. Ishii looks risky. And beware of Winn, who hit 266 on grass, were he now will play on. Having said that, i might keep Winn over the other 2 simply for his sb.