I didn't like Takatsu last year, and was obviously proven completely wrong as he had a really fine season aftre being names closer. I still don't see how he can get hitters out with that crap he throws, but I guess he's been doing it for a lot of years in Japan, and now here for at least last season. Thus, the "Mr.Zero" tag.
That said, I am all about "stuff" and he just doesn't have any. I still think he gets blown out at some point and loses the gig to Hermanson. Meanwhile, Batista looks well suited to be a closer, and I believe he'll have a very solid season, so he's my choice here.