Which Mariners Pitchers are worth owning? THE 3Ms & wannabe

[Titanic Grizzlie]

Let's assume 12 team 5x5 leagues for this discussion. What value do see these 3Ms have and how do you see them finishing this year? With SEA lineup and being in a pitcher' spark at least one of these guys will win 15 games and have a sub 4 ERA. which one will it be?


Moyer Meche Madritscch

heck lets throw the wannabe "M" Mr. Mpiniero in there as well


I like em in this order:

Piniero
Madritsch
Moyer
Meche

[This is the year]

I like Mpineiro myself

[mikegp]

Meche
Moyer
Madritscch

...I'd probably put Pinerio first but you didn't include him on your list so I assume he's taken. I might put Madritscch ahead of Moyer as well. Most people probably won't agree with me but I think Meche will have a great year.

[sportsgalore]

I like Mpineiro myself

lol - thought that was a typo at first, it's a little late and im a little slow

i like pineiro and madritsch
not a big fan of moyer or meche myself

and no SEA pitcher is a safe(co) bet - wow, that's lame...sorry...

[Titanic Grizzlie]

I didn't include piniero because he is taken in most 12 team leagues while the other three are normally FAs.

[studplaya1114]

I like Mpineiro myself

yea, dont exclude Mpineiro, but lets hope that he doesnt stay on the DL for long. You may be able to trade for him cheap.
1. Mpineiro
2. Madristch
3. Meche
4. Moyer

[CBV]

i have moyer and pineiro on my team. moyer picked up a solid W today against the twins.


also, i enjoyed the opening day pitchers duel today at US Comiskular field, i got sunburned, and i actually saw a sweet one to nothing game at sox park. amazing. beuhrle looked very nice, tadahito went 0-2 in the count his first 3 times up. im a little scared there....otherwise


offtopic i know but im trying to occupy my mind with something other than my illini losing a game they had in their grasp.

[thehat]

Meche has the most upside. If he finally gains some consistency, he could be a breakout pitcher.

The other two aren't worth owning. Moyer was fine today, but I really don't see him being able to maintain this strong start. Could be wrong on that count, but his lack of K's limits his usefulness at any rate.

Madritsch was a bit of a fluke last season, I suspect. Determined competitor, but his stuff isn't great, and his mechanics were pretty bad in the game he pitched here in LV over the weekend. His shoulder was flying open early, causing the ball to sail, and he gave up some real bombs.

[Titanic Grizzlie]

All right fellas let's open this up to piniero as well.

Piniero
Madritsch
Moyer
Meche

[hybrid]

I think Felix Her ... oh my bad, he isn't in the rotation yet.

In that case I'm thinking Meche can put it together this year, and I think could be better then Piniero .... whenever he comes back.