Leaguewide debate....

[agchris02]

There were 3 teams in the draft I did yesterday that turned out VERY well off, I think the others were idiots, and we're debating on whose team is the best:

Team A Team B Team C

1b: D Ortiz Jim Thome A Pujols
2b: M Loretta C Utley A Soriano
3b: A Rodriguez T Batista T Glaus
SS: O Cabrera N Garciapara D Jeter
C: J Estrada P Lo Duca J Posada
OF: M Cabrera G Anderson JD Drew
OF: G Sheffield J Bay S Sosa
OF: J Damon V Wells P Wilson
U: T Hafner C Delgado C Jones
P1:R Oswalt R Johnson R Clemens
P2:R Harden M Mussina A Eaton
P3:B Colon Oliver Perez D Graves
P4:J Vazquez B Wagner T Hudson
P5: M Buehrle D Wells D Kolb
P6:J Thompson B Zito P Martinez
P7: B Radke Z Grienke D Willis

B1:D Wright B Bonds R Ortiz
B2:L Berkman J Peavy CC Sabbathia
B3:C Paterson A Kearns J Suppan
B4:J Lieber C Crisp J Wright
B5:E Loaiza Tori Hunter B Webb


There really arent any other teams which appear as to have a chance (my personal favorit is A )

Oh, and its a cbs H2H pts league

Scoring for Batting Categories
1B - Singles 1 point
2B - Doubles 2 points
3B - Triples 3 points
BB - Walks (Batters) 1 point
HR - Home Runs 4 points
R - Runs 1 point
RBI - Runs Batted In 1 point
SB - Stolen Bases 2 points

Scoring for Pitching Categories
BBI - Walks Issued (Pitchers) -0.5 points
CG - Complete Games 5 points
ER - Earned Runs -1 point
HA - Hits Allowed -0.5 points
INN - Innings 2 points
K - Strikeouts (Pitcher) 1 point
S - Saves 10 points
W - Wins 10 points


start any 7 pitchers, dont have to have RP if you dont want

[Yanks 4ev]

i gotta go with team b esp if bonds comes back this season

[Dlepz]

I think team C is the best.

[just_A_girl]

A and C are very close but I think I'd give the edge to C because they have so much more pitching. Offensively, A's slightly better than C.

[DK]

There were 3 teams in the draft I did yesterday that turned out VERY well off, I think the others were idiots, and we're debating on whose team is the best:

Team A Team B Team C

1b: D Ortiz Jim Thome A Pujols Edge: C
2b: M Loretta C Utley A Soriano Edge: C
3b: A Rodriguez T Batista T Glaus Edge: A
SS: O Cabrera N Garciapara D Jeter Edge: B or C
C: J Estrada P Lo Duca J Posada Edge: C
OF: M Cabrera G Anderson JD Drew
OF: G Sheffield J Bay S Sosa
OF: J Damon V Wells P Wilson Edge: A
U: T Hafner C Delgado C Jones Edge: A or B
P1:R Oswalt R Johnson R Clemens
P2:R Harden M Mussina A Eaton
P3:B Colon Oliver Perez D Graves
P4:J Vazquez B Wagner T Hudson
P5: M Buehrle D Wells D Kolb
P6:J Thompson B Zito P Martinez
P7: B Radke Z Grienke D Willis Edge SP: Toss-up Edge RP: C by default...

B1:D Wright B Bonds R Ortiz
B2:L Berkman J Peavy CC Sabbathia
B3:C Paterson A Kearns J Suppan
B4:J Lieber C Crisp J Wright
B5:E Loaiza Tori Hunter B WebbEdge: A or B

I can tell (like you said) RP aren't necessary, but when a save is worth as much as a win, I'd STOCK on closers and forget starters whatsoever.