Who would you rather have?? Matt Holliday or Garret Anderson

[Melo255]

Anderson: .305 85 30 120
Holliday: .285 80 25 90
Holliday will probably have great numbers at home and be useless on the road. I intend on using him this year in a split role with someone like Nixon for a great combo but all alone or if you can't waste 2 spots for 1 then he isn't worth much.

[jayman]

GA is more likely to succeed. Nothing against Holliday, but he's less likely to succeed.

[pomplona's finest]

I really like Holliday this year, but unless Anderson suffers significantly from injury squabbles don't expect this comparison to be close.

[thehat]

I like Holliday to improve on last year's numbers across the board. But I like GA a lot more.

[Iconoclastic]

In a keeper league Holliday's upside inches his value up. But I would still take Anderson hitting behind Vlad.

[bleach168]

GA > Holliday

GA < Holliday + Nixon

[Iconoclastic]

GA > Holliday

GA < Holliday + Nixon

GA > Holliday on the road + Nixon facing a lefty