the guy has to be a lock for 25 hr, .275-.280, 80 runs, 80 rbi. Certianly not a world beater, but definitely has value.
I mean, yea, pujols, helton, ortiz, tex, thome, konerko, hafner, dunn, casey, huff, lee, delgado, sexson are preferable options. The rest is a judgment call IMO. In leagues with a util and CI, CI can become thin IMO. He is useful there I think.
Although, the one I can't decide on -- ibanez and green higher or lower than bagwell? I ask because bagwell always has the "name" with him, so if he gets hot, you move him. The other two are preferable probably if he is totally done.