Giles vs. Uribe

[AtlDynasty25]

I am going to be pursuing one of these two in a trade, as I am pretty week at 2B with Louis Castillo. Which of these two do you think will have a better year? Giles will probably hit for a higher average, but Uribe may have a slight edge in power. Stolen bases are useless to me as I am punting that category, so disregarding stolen bases, who has the better year this year???

[hybrid]

Giles is the easy pick for me. I don't trust Uribe to stay consistent or reproduce his numbers, also he won't be hitting in the top of the line up with Iguchi hitting 2nd now. Giles will have a better avg. and more runs, hr's and rbi's should fairly be close.

[j_d_mcnugent]

when healthy, giles is easily the better option. i am concerned that uribe wont be able to replicate last years numbers.