Matt Holliday or Larry Walker

[Tokugawa]

Who is going to have the better year?

[R-man]

Walker.

[SaintsOfTheDiamond]

Probably Walker, even if he does only play 115 games. I'm not sure what the current situation with Holliday is, but if it's a keeper, I think you take him and just wait this year out, because in COL he could be a very good player in a year or two I think.

[Gizmo]

Holliday, he has the potential to break out in a big way. Walker is on the decline. Holliday has had a good pre-season and it is tough to overlook the Coors factor,

[bselig]

Better year? Walker if he stays healthy. If not, Holliday may put up better cumulative stats. I suppose they can be viewed as similar, non-complete players: Holliday a good player for the 81 games he plays at Coors and Walker a good payer for however long he can stay healthy. I would rather have Walker.

[Pacman]

Walker can be a nice value pick. I got him with my 18th pick, and if he works out, great, if not, no huge problem. If you're in a keeper, Holliday is a better choice, otherwise I like Walker.