Which OF you like best???

[Havok1517]

Reg 5X5, 25 man roster, Keeper League, 25th round

C. Biggio (Hou - OF, 2B)
M. Kotsay (Oak - OF)
J. Jones (Min - OF)
E. Byrnes (Oak - OF)
C. Floyd (NYM - OF)
M. Lawton

[so0perspam]

Jacque Jones.

[Havok1517]

Reg 5X5, 25 man roster, Keeper League, 25th round

C. Biggio (Hou - OF, 2B)
M. Kotsay (Oak - OF)
J. Jones (Min - OF)
E. Byrnes (Oak - OF)
C. Floyd (NYM - OF)
M. Lawton (Pit - OF)

12 Team 5X5 Keeper 25 Man Roster
C - Ramon Hernandez
1B - Paul Konerko
2B - Brian Roberts
3B - Eric Chavez
SS - Cesar Izturis
OF - Jim Edmonds
OF - Vernon Wells
OF - J.D. Drew
Util - Aramis Ramirez
Util - Shawn Green
Bench - Khalil Greene
Bench - Dmitri Young
Bench

SP - Roy Oswalt
SP - Pedro Martinez
RP - Billy Wagner
RP - Guillermo Mota
P - A.J. Burnett
P - Feddy Garcia
P - Jon Lieber
Bench - Jeff Weaver
Bench - Adam Eaton
Bench - Kyle Lohse
Bench - Ugueth Urbina
Bench - Mike Gonzalez


Now who is your pick?

[so0perspam]

Still Jacque .... or tell me if I'm missing something that should make my selection change.

[Havok1517]

For some reason I think Biggio will have the most value due to his 2B eligibility. I need some speed pretty bad, considering Roberts is my best option I have, Lawton stole the most last year, then Byrnes, then Jones. Also, I hear Jones will be traded.

[nuggets]

Still Jacque .... or tell me if I'm missing something that should make my selection change.

_______R....HR....RBI...SB.....AVG
Lawton 109...20....70......23......277

Jones....69....24....80......13......254



Lawton's #s are pretty peak and Jones has potential to improve more but if you sb over hr and rbi go with Lawton. With Kendall gone there should be room for as many as 95 runs for a guy like Lawton hitting #1 or #3 for Pittsburg.. Lawton's career single-season best AVG is higher than Jones. Lawton's career OBP is 41 points higher than Jones'.

Jones is the more secure pick even without Lawton's move to the National league but if you take the risk on Lawton reacting well to National league pitching you could end up with the more productive player. I'd only take Lawton if you have secure players and needed some SB.

[wrveres]

I like Lawton here too ..

But if your MI is suspect, then I might take Biggio.

[ravenmad22]

Lawton.

[Rubidium]

Lawton Jones should rebound, but not to be more valuable than Lawton.