Is Texeria and Cabrera really that much of a toss-up?

[Guttenburg]

Their stats from last year would seem to suggest as such.

[TheYanks04]

Can't really go wrong with either imo. As to who will be more valuable, who knows really. Comes down to personal preference really as I do not htink there is a lot of difference in projected value between the 2. Tex has a bit more power...MCab will get you a better avg in all liklihood, but that is about the extent of it.

[baseballnewb]

I'd call Cabrera the safer pick. He was very consistant last year. Teix had one big month that really inflated his stats, of course he was also hurt for a bit which deflated his stats some as well. I just feel safer with Cabrera. He's also in a position thats not as deep in my opinion.

[RynMan]

Yeah I dunno who I would take if given the chance. Probably Cabrera.

[curious_george_43545]

I have Cabrera one spot ahead of Teixeira in my rankings

[cordscords]

Cabrera will give you early 1st round talent as a late 2nd round pick. This will be the year he takes it to a whole new level. M-Cab easy.

[-Slap-]

Cabrera by a nose. He seems to go off the board 5-10 picks ahead of Tex in most drafts.

[DieHardCubbie]

I like MCab a little better as well...both should give you very solid numbers across the board..but MCabs average will be slightly higher...

[Amazinz]

I agree that you can't go wrong with either one. Cabrera is definite 2nd round material IMO and Tex is more borderline 2nd/3rd. I'd be happy with either but it's not that close for me. I'm taking Cabrera if he's there.

[HOOTIE]

Both are close, but i like Tex more this year. He's a switch hitter, has the park advantage, and had the better 2nd half.