Guillen Vs Drew

[cordscords]

Just a quick answer. Who would you rather have, Jose Guillen or JD Drew?

[The Miner Part 2]

drew. guillen has to show us more.

[Dodger Blue]

Drew for now but Guillen is interesting

[CubsFan7724]

Its close, but I like Drew just by a hair. I think Guillen will do well hitting behind Vidro and Wilkinson.

[toofunnyy]

guillen is way overrated

[The Natural]

Drew by a little. More, if I knew he would stay healthy.

[mmdmaznn]

If Drew stays healthy, he should post solid numbers this year. Guillen will post OK numbers, but Drew will get you a few more SB's and will probably get you more R and RBI's in his line-up.

Gotta go with Drew here.

[CrazyPooja90]

I am going to have to say Guillen. 1) I actually like the Nationals lineup this year 2) I can't see Drew not making an appearence on the DL this year and 3) I just think he's better. He has more power and quicker hands then Drew. Plus the Dodger's park won't exactly help Drew's stats

Edit: Some how I read Carlos and not Jose.

Go with Drew

[Melo255]

I am going to have to say Guillen. 1) I actually like the Nationals lineup this year 2) I can't see Drew not making an appearence on the DL this year and 3) I just think he's better. He has more power and quicker hands then Drew. Plus the Dodger's park won't exactly help Drew's stats

Edit: Some how I read Jose and not Carlos.

Go with Drew

You DID read Jose. I think a lot depends on whether or not the Nationals stadium ends up being a hitters park or not. Guillen looks very close to a sure bet for .300 and 30 home runs minimum. If his park helps him and the rest of the Nationals lineup performs well his numbers could be very good. I agree that Drew is more than likely to end up on the DL for part of the year and moving to Dodger Stadium might hurt his stats more than some think. Because of that I give the tiniest of edges to Guillen.

[so0perspam]

Drew by a fair margin.