Hidalgo, Holliday, Mench, W.M. Pena - Please rank

[curious_george_43545]

Holliday is the best, but only when he's at home...pick up Holliday and paly him during home games and paly soemone else when he's not....otherwise overall

Mench
Hidalgo
Holliday
Willy Mo Pena

[CubsFan7724]

I like
Hidalgo
Mench
Holliday
Pena

[RynMan]

Hidalgo this year

.275, 35 HR, 100RBI, 85 Runs

Not too shabby. Id be shocked if anyone else on that list matches those numbers.

[reiser]

What kind of platoon are Holliday and Mench in? Holliday's the starting LF (Hawpe/Mohr is the platoon), while Dellucci/Colbrunn is the DH platoon in Texas.

I was thinking of Nix, you're correct.

Earlier in the spring there was talk of Holliday/Piedra platooning, but I guess Holliday has erased that. Interestingly, Sportsline Mentions Hawpe as the better prospect. They're both 25/26, in any rate.

[Secret Avatar]

I like Hidalgo. Although he's been freakishly inconsistent in BA, the dude can HIT. He's now in Texas, hitting in a great hitters park, and in a great line-up. He'll likely bat fifth. Hitting behind Tex should be all good. I see something like 280-30-95-90-2 with a good chance of 290-35-105-95. Or, maybe he has a monster year like he did in 2000, when he posted 314-44-122-118-13. In any event, he'll cost as much as a handful of dirt in this year's draft. I drafted him in something like the 18th round of my 12-team league two weeks ago.

[j_d_mcnugent]

I like
Hidalgo
Mench
Holliday
Pena

[HollywoodHershiserz]

Mench
Hidalgo
Holliday
Pena

To start the season, Hidalgo will bat 5th and Mench will follow him. Both can definetly mash the ball, but Mench has potential for more homeruns without doing too much damage in batting average. I can see both hitting 30+, but can see Mench moving up to 5th spot and solidfying himself as a stud and breakthrough player this year.

[GameOn]

I like
Hidalgo
Mench
Holliday
Pena

I concur