Rate These teams and get a cookie!

[so0perspam]

I voted B. Team A's top three starters are pretty nice, but I do not like Webb at all. Team B's hitting and relief domination give it the edge, though I wouldn't be hanging onto Leiter if I were team B.

OK, now where's my cookie? I want oatmeal if we get a choice.

Agreed about the team and the oatmeal.

[eftda]

Team B's lack of pitching and bench makes it the weaker of the two teams. But the power in team B is strong than in team A. Team A has the better pitching and its bench is much deeper.

[Transmogrifier]

I like team B, too. It has weaker pitching, but if s/he is smart with the wire, that would be ok. Team As hitting is too weak in my opinion.

[eftda]

Estrada > Liberthal
Konerko < Teix
womack = castillo
Rolen > Blalock
Figgions = furcal
Edmonds < Ramirez
Alou< Matsui
Wilson = Giles
Mora > Walker
J. Wilson > K. Mench


imo

[so0perspam]

Estrada > Liberthal
Konerko < Teix
womack = castillo
Wrong!
Rolen > Blalock
Figgions = furcal
Wrong!
Edmonds < Ramirez
Alou< Matsui
Wilson = Giles
Wrong!
Mora > Walker
J. Wilson > K. Mench
Wrong!


imo

[eftda]

So I did the satts and here is what they came out to. I used the 2004 stats for the starters for the hitters. I totaled the stats used in the league, and divided by 10 (we can start only 10). I only used the stats for those in the line up

Team A

R: 92
HR:24
RBI:87
SB:9
AVG:.276
TB:280

Team B

R:.89
HR:24
RBI:84
SB:8
AVG:.253
TB:259

[kentx12]

Getting a little scared huh. This is this year not last year. Buddy

[so0perspam]

Stop trying so hard eftda . Team B is just ..... hrrm let me find the word ..... better.

[eftda]

Getting a little scared huh. This is this year not last year. Buddy

1/2 the people at the cafe vote or post from their guy, not stats.

[studplaya1114]

Estrada > Liberthal
Konerko < Teix
womack = castillo
Wrong!
Rolen > Blalock
Figgions = furcal
Wrong!
Edmonds < Ramirez
Alou< Matsui
Wilson = Giles
Wrong!
Mora > Walker
J. Wilson > K. Mench
Wrong!


imo

I agree with sooperman
Overall, Team B has a definite advantage over team A. Team A locks up 3-4 pitching cats, but Team B locks up 5-6 of the hitting categories.

So I did the satts and here is what they came out to. I used the 2004 stats for the starters for the hitters. I totaled the stats used in the league, and divided by 10 (we can start only 10). I only used the stats for those in the line up

Team A

R: 92
HR:24
RBI:87
SB:9
AVG:.276
TB:280

Team B

R:.89
HR:24
RBI:84
SB:8
AVG:.253
TB:259

Keep in mind that Kevin Mench and Larry Walker didnt play full seasons, while every starter in Team A completed an entire season