Which rookie will have the greatest impact THIS year?

[quietstorm]

On second thought, maybe Marte will have the most impact, indirectly, by forcing Chipper to rebound.

[The Miner Part 2]

Mauer's not considered a rookie anymore, right? Because if he is then he would definately be my pick

well bonds isnt a rookie anymore, but if he was id pick him.

[Surfs up]

Swisher

[Nene]

Swisher

'bout what do you expect from him?

[Surfs up]

Not a great average. If he hits above .250 I would be happy . But 25-28 hrs. 80-85 Rbi , 80-85 runs scored. maybe a few more runs. He's on the lines of Troy Glaus. Good everthing but average.Oh and ROY IMO

[sammyfan711]

Not a great average. If he hits above .250 I would be happy . But 25-28 hrs. 80-85 Rbi , 80-85 runs scored. maybe a few more runs. He's on the lines of Troy Glaus. Good everthing but average.Oh and ROY IMO

And tons of walks if your league counts them or OBP. I love Swisher this year as well.

[SHOCKandAWE]

Swisher

He probably will platoon with C Thomas and will have to do well to get full time at bats

[Iconoclastic]

Where's the love for Garrett Atkins? Starting 3B in Colorado??? Even half of Vinny Castilla, which shouldn't be too hard, should challenge for ROY

[hybrid]

Kazmir would be my bet, but I like high reward rookies. The rest I don't think are capable of doing anything great or special this year that will make a big difference to your team. Kazmir however could, though he is somewhat risky.

edited: to whoever saw it, oops I thought he was talking about Sizemore

[AKhomebrewer]

I'd go with Reed.
Then Swisher,
then Jeff Francis.