C. Zambrano or Meche

[Guest]

I have Zambrano and thinking of dropping him for Meche. What do you think? Is this a good move?

[just passing through]

what does carlos zambrano have to do to stay in your lineup? make your bed? wash your dishes? he's been great this year!

i guess if you staff is so good you could drop him, i'd try to trade him to upgrade somewhere else.

[point06]

zambrano has been pitching really well, and even though meche has been pitching great, i dont see him as being as proven as zambrano. stick with zambrano.

[YankFan51]

Easy with the Zambrano ass kissing. He's a WHIP nightmare. I wouldn't say he constitutes an automatic guy to have. I dropped him yesterday in fact. I got enough pitching that I don't want him ruining my WHIP.

[quickfingerz]

i see meche with fewer strikeouts, a lower WHIP (he has nice control), more wins (better run support), and a lower ERA (one thing that helps is that seattle is a less friendly hitters park than ChC's)

[Madison]

I'd stick with Zambrano. I've seen both of them pitch a few games (thank you satellite dish!) and I'm not overally sold on Meche. His numbers are very good, but I'm not sure they will hold up.