Gagne and Looper or Gagne and Alfonseca or..?

[Juhlz]

I have been shuffling around my closer situation. I am about middle of the pack on saves and have recently dropped Alfonseca and picked up Looper to compliment Gagne. Is this a good move? I also had Dotel and dropped him for G Meche. Is this a good move? Thanks for your input!

[bleach168]

Looper is a better pitcher and has a lot more job security than alfonseca. Good move. I haven't seen Meche pitch, but I would imagine keeping Dotel would have been safer, but who knows, if you've seen Meche you know better than me.

[Juhlz]

I grabbed Meche after he shutout the Yankees in NY, no easy feat. Dotel offers huge k numbers for innings pitched, low whip and era though. Tough call. Thanks for the feedback