Which one ? Konerko or Suzuki

[Secret Avatar]

This is the no-brainer of all no-brainers: ICHIRO by a lightyear.

[AKhomebrewer]

When faced with the choice between one player who has been solidly consistent for four years, vs. a guy who has bounced from good to a bum to career year in the last three seasons, I'll go with the consistency.

Ichiro.

[williesd]

I wouldn't keep either of them. Worst case you can get Ichiro back at a $ or 2 over $33. You might get him for $30? I would be surprised if he went $35 or higher.

[Surfs up]

Getting Ichiro back for $33.00 would be to much of a gamble. Our league over pays by 20-20% from the dollar projections I have seen on sites. I was leaning toward keeping Suzuki anyway. I just needed you guys to confirm my decision. Thanks for all the replies.