Adopted Dynasty Draft Help?

[acw9293]

I adopted an absolutely awful dynasty team, 8-team league. After a bunch of trading, I am left with:
SP: Garza, Parker, Latos, Moore
RP: Chapman
C: Y. Molina
1B: Rizzo, Encarnacion, Teixeira
2B: Phillips
3B: N/A
SS: Andrus
OF: CarGo

I have made improvement, but the problem is I am left with the #1 pick, then no picks until round 6.
Obviously my team isn't built to contend this season, but I'm thinking next year could be one of contending.

So, with my #1 pick, do I go for: BJ Upton, Manny Machado, Tim Lincecum, Trevor Bauer, or Wil Myers?
I don't want to let one of the upside guys like Machado, Bauer, or Myers slip through my fingers because I'm not sure they'll be there in round 6 and I'm building for the future, but I'm torn.

Advice?

[Brainstorm]

I would def take Upton here, his countables would be a huge addition to your team. And in an 8-team league, you never know, you could end up having a chance if you draft well...

[acw9293]

Is he worth the risk of losing out on 10+ years of Machado? That's where my concern lies.

[HOOTIE]

Machado
BJ
Myers

[MadDog36]

Trade Tex for a draft pick or two or a pick and a young SP arm (maybe Medlen?)
Manny Machado is the way I'd go myself, though common logic you take the best available player which in this case is Upton.

Does E-5 still carry 3b eligbility he might carry it for one more season in some leagues.

[dleoboyd]

Machado would by my pick of that group.

[acw9293]

Unfortunately Edwin only has 1B eligibility this season, and nobody in my league wants Tex. Tried that already! It looks like I'm stuck with what I have at this point.