Drop Damn McDonald? WHIR

[jruffus1]

I am so disappointed in James McDonald. He had such a good game going, but then become totally unravelled in the 5th (6 run 5th). Is it time to dump him once and for all? He has been killing my ERA.

[KingOfSports]

With only 1 QS in his last 6 appearances, no one would blame you if you did.

[germani40]

Hes been a different pitcher in the 2nd half. I would dump him in 10-12 team leagues for any solid options on the wire.


viewtopic.php?t=451633

[handyman01]

Need more info (# of teams, who else you have, roto or h2h, replacement options, etc). Hard to say without that. He could still prove to be a useful matchups pitcher down the stretch in some leagues.

viewtopic.php?t=451623

[guilly_99]

I think he's done and he won't regain his composure from pre-AS break. I would say for the rest of the season, expect a 4.40 ERA so if you're ok with that, keep him. Otherwise, dump him and I bet you can find a better FA starter over the rest of the season.

Please help: viewtopic.php?t=451634

[sclyon3]

I picked him up early and have been high on him all year. That being said, I dropped him this past week also. If you can't handle the Padres at home, you can't handle no one.

It's time to move on....