Trade 2 of Cueto, Jo Johnson, Haren, Zimm for Kershaw + WHIR

[footballisbetter.com]

An owner wants 2 of the following pitchers of mine (Cueto, Josh Johnson, Haren and J Zimmermann).

He will give me Kershaw, and with the extra roster spot I would pick up one of Beckett, Wandy, J Parker, Bedard, Bud Norris, Minor, W Chen all on WW.

Should I trade any 2 of the above for Kershaw + one of the WW pickups?

These are my starters.
Cueto, Hellickson, Josh Johnson, Haren, Wainwright, T Hanson, J Zimmermann

[nyr199435]

Well I wouldn't give him Cueto. I would probably do Johnson and Haren for Kershaw, but I doubt he'd take it. If he would though, that's the move. I'd like to keep Cueto and Zimm if I were you.

[LUISAO]

give zimmerman and haren and pick wandy....if you get lucky

[ATLbraves]

Well I wouldn't give him Cueto. I would probably do Johnson and Haren for Kershaw, but I doubt he'd take it. If he would though, that's the move. I'd like to keep Cueto and Zimm if I were you.

I completely agree.




help with mine please:
viewtopic.php?t=451570

[germani40]

kind of agreeing with the other guys. i would deal johnson, haren, zimmerman in that order. zimmerman is in consideration because i wouldnt be shocked if they get a big enough lead in the division they skip him every once in a while

[jeffro10]

I'd only do it for Haren and JJ. Also, I say pick up Parker, not Wandy for sure. Please answer mine.

viewtopic.php?t=451599

[sigriffey]

Well I wouldn't give him Cueto. I would probably do Johnson and Haren for Kershaw, but I doubt he'd take it. If he would though, that's the move. I'd like to keep Cueto and Zimm if I were you.

I completely agree.


Agree as well

help with mine please:
viewtopic.php?t=451570

[footballisbetter.com]

Thanks all. So it seems most think I should trade Josh Johnson and Dan Haren for Kershaw?

If I do this deal, I'm leaning towards either Minor or Parker off the WW.

So my question would be is Kershaw/Minor or Parker > Josh Johnson/Haren?

[ATLbraves]

Thanks all. So it seems most think I should trade Josh Johnson and Dan Haren for Kershaw?

If I do this deal, I'm leaning towards either Minor or Parker off the WW.

So my question would be is Kershaw/Minor or Parker > Josh Johnson/Haren?

I think so. I do like Minor and Parker but I would go with Parker until Minor is able to show more consistency.

[LittleTree]

I have traded both J. Johnson and Haren this year myself, and I am glad I did. If you can pick up someone like Kershaw I would do it in a heartbeat. If this is a keeper even more so.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=451611