Pick 12 to keep WHIR

[Iguana]

Standard 5x5 league with MI/CI, start 2 C's and 10 P's.


C Napoli
2B Phillips
3B Zimmerman
SS Reyes
OF C.Gonzalez
OF J.Hamilton
OF A.Soriano
OF Stubbs
OF L.Scott

P F.Hernandez
P Liriano
P Soria
P Lilly
P CJ Wilson
P Bumgarner
P I.Kennedy
P J.Zimmerman
P D.Storen

[HOOTIE]

Standard 5x5 league with MI/CI, start 2 C's and 10 P's.


C Napoli
2B Phillips
3B Zimmerman
SS Reyes
OF C.Gonzalez
OF J.Hamilton
OF A.Soriano
OF Stubbs
OF L.Scott

P F.Hernandez
P Liriano
P Soria
P Lilly
P CJ Wilson
P Bumgarner
P I.Kennedy
P J.Zimmerman
P D.Storen

[manalishi]

viewtopic.php?t=419876

Standard 5x5 league with MI/CI, start 2 C's and 10 P's.


C Napoli
2B Phillips
--3B Zimmerman
--SS Reyes
--OF C.Gonzalez
--OF J.Hamilton
OF A.Soriano
OF Stubbs
OF L.Scott

--P F.Hernandez
--P Liriano
--P Soria
P Lilly
P CJ Wilson
P Bumgarner
P I.Kennedy
P J.Zimmerman
--P D.Storen

That's 8 of the 12. I'd keep another pitcher or two from the remaining group, plus possibly Napoli depending on whether he gets traded. If you think Phillips gets back on track, then he's another possibility.

[RunReyesRun]

Standard 5x5 league with MI/CI, start 2 C's and 10 P's.


C Napoli
2B Phillips
3B Zimmerman
SS Reyes
OF C.Gonzalez
OF J.Hamilton
OF A.Soriano
OF Stubbs
OF L.Scott

P F.Hernandez
P Liriano
P Soria
P Lilly
P CJ Wilson
P Bumgarner
P I.Kennedy
P J.Zimmerman
P D.Storen

[raiders_umpire]

C Napoli
2B Phillips
3B Zimmerman
SS Reyes
OF C.Gonzalez
OF J.Hamilton
OF Stubbs


P F.Hernandez
P Liriano
P Soria
P Bumgarner
P J.Zimmerman

[FrankieYankee]

C Napoli
2B Phillips
3B Zimmerman
SS Reyes
OF C.Gonzalez
OF J.Hamilton
OF Stubbs


P F.Hernandez
P Liriano
P Soria
P Bumgarner
P J.Zimmerman
HELP!

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=419894

[Iguana]

Thanks for the help everyone, very interesting. Seems a clear consensus on the 7 hitters, plus King Felix, Liriano, Soria and Bumgarner.

For that final spot people seem split on Storen or Zimmermann. What's the case for one over the other? And why not Wilson or Lilly?

[zippytrash]

Standard 5x5 league with MI/CI, start 2 C's and 10 P's.


C Napoli
2B Phillips
3B Zimmerman
SS Reyes
OF C.Gonzalez
OF J.Hamilton
OF A.Soriano
OF Stubbs
OF L.Scott

P F.Hernandez
P Liriano
P Soria
P Lilly
P CJ Wilson
P Bumgarner
P I.Kennedy
P J.Zimmerman
P D.Storen

[ayebatter]

Thanks for the help everyone, very interesting. Seems a clear consensus on the 7 hitters, plus King Felix, Liriano, Soria and Bumgarner.

For that final spot people seem split on Storen or Zimmermann. What's the case for one over the other? And why not Wilson or Lilly?

Lilly is 34 yrs old, Wilson just threw 130 innings more than '09, and I'm keeping Kennedy over Zimmerman.