EDIT: since the consensus is that Lince for Manny is a bad deal..
what about Haren or Felix? If i could get Manny for either of them straight up do i do it?
another option i was thinking about was throwing niemann into the deal as well and getting a closer in return, either fuentes or soria. what do you all think about those possibilities?
I'm currently in first place in my h2h league, scoring categories are the normal 5x5 ones plus OPS(hitting) and Losses(pitching)
With Beltran on the DL and Lowell possibly following, i'm in need of some hitting help. Manny is available, as well as BJ Upton, and the guy is looking for a starting pitcher. Which one of my guys would be the best to offer him for either manny or upton? Keep in mind that this is a keeper league, so greinke who i got pretty late in the draft has alot of value compared to maybe lince, who i got in the 2nd or 3rd round and would have to surrender a 1st round pick to keep.
my roster:
C McCann C Inge 1b Pujols 2b Utley 3b Chris Davis ss Michael Young ci Loney mi Ian Stewart of Holliday of Bobby Abreu of Michael Bourn of Aaron Rowand of Colby Rasmus util Mike Lowell dl Beltran
sp Lincecum sp Haren sp Greinke sp Felix Hernandez rp Heath Bell rp Brian Wilson rp Valverde p Street p Kazmir bench Wakefield bench Niemann
Last edited by kenjinenjin on Tue Jun 30, 2009 7:26 pm, edited 3 times in total.
Lincecum could very well be a CY winner again this season. Manny has his roid drama, he hasnt swung a bat in forever, hes old, etc. not a chance. keep your ace.
oh wow, and its keeper? Lincecum will be your ace for a long time. Manny is heading into the twilight of his career.
C Posey 1B Fielder 2B Pedroia SS Scutaro 3B Headley OF Kemp OF McCutchen OF A.Gonzalez UT Pagan BN Bautista Victorino Utley Machado Stubbs W.Chen Marcum J.Garcia
Lincecum could very well be a CY winner again this season. Manny has his roid drama, he hasnt swung a bat in forever, hes old, etc. not a chance. keep your ace.
oh wow, and its keeper? Lincecum will be your ace for a long time. Manny is heading into the twilight of his career.
I agree with danvan. There is No Way I would give up Lincecum up for Manny.
Lincecum could very well be a CY winner again this season. Manny has his roid drama, he hasnt swung a bat in forever, hes old, etc. not a chance. keep your ace.
oh wow, and its keeper? Lincecum will be your ace for a long time. Manny is heading into the twilight of his career.
I agree with danvan. There is No Way I would give up Lincecum up for Manny.
plz help with my topic. thanks!
C Posey 1B Fielder 2B Pedroia SS Scutaro 3B Headley OF Kemp OF McCutchen OF A.Gonzalez UT Pagan BN Bautista Victorino Utley Machado Stubbs W.Chen Marcum J.Garcia
keep lincecum...if you want to trade him im sure you could get this trade done but still, lincecum was rated higher at the beginning of the season for a reason!
what about Haren or Felix? If i could get Manny for either of them straight up do i do it?
another option i was thinking about was throwing niemann into the deal as well and getting a closer in return, either fuentes or soria. what do you all think about those possibilities?
kenjinenjin wrote:what about Haren or Felix? If i could get Manny for either of them straight up do i do it?
another option i was thinking about was throwing niemann into the deal as well and getting a closer in return, either fuentes or soria. what do you all think about those possibilities?
Keeper league - I'd keep Felix. Maybe try Haren if you really want to get Manny. Just keep in mind that he's in his late 30's and might now have been scared into quitting the roids and might show his age with whatever years he has left. I wouldn't be dying to get him. Certainly try to get a closer along with him if you do indeed give up a really good pitcher for him
Cafe Home
Fantasy Football
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
by kenjinenjin » Mon Jun 29, 2009 2:23 am 
/charlie1.gif)
