Holliday/Verlander for Kemp/Slowey? (Changed)

[TeamMikeDeveraux]

Hey guys,
This offer is on the table:

Give: Holliday and Verlander
Get: Kemp and Slowey

Lets hear it!! WHIR

12Team H2H 5x5 non-keeper
C Ianetta
1B Votto
2B Utley
3B ARamirez
SS Tulo
IF DeRosa (3B/2B/OF)
OF Braun, Holliday, Markakis, McLouth
Util Hart
BN Hardy, Fowler

SP Lincecum, Cain, Volquez, Nolasco, Verlander, Carmona
RP Capps, Gregg, Madson
BN Pelfrey, Ubaldo Jimenez
DL Kelvim Escobar, Bonderman

[jermhorse]

WOW, Kemp is a very good player but, We are talking about Matt Holiday, the baseball player right?
Because the only way I would make that trade was if we were talking about Matt Holiday the actor.

you would not be the first that ive heard jumping ship when it comes to the new oakland left fielder, but I feel that both Verlander and Holiday are going to have productive years. IMO

I also dont think that Kemp is a Pujols, Ham Ram, type worthy of such a trade but then again, I thought George Bush would never get elected a second term.

best of luck anyway and I would love your opinion about this one whir
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=382523

[METS 24]

Deleted

[TeamMikeDeveraux]

Thanks guys,
The guy actually said he would include Slowey now that Verlander is tearing it up again today. Would you do the new trade of:
Give: Holliday/Verlander
Get: Kemp/Slowey

[col24]

I would hold onto them!

viewtopic.php?t=382606

[jermhorse]

That is definently better ImO. I have to ask what you r motivation is here. Are you just stoked on Kemp or disgusted with Holliday. Because if it is the later then I would recomend just holding tight. But kemp and Slowey is a good deal. I could go either way. but i like holliday

[TeamMikeDeveraux]

I love christina model. Thanks for the help guys. My motivation was originally disgust with Holliday (but then I realized he will likely be traded at the deadline) and increased speed, but I think Id rather go for a true speed guy like Upton or Ellsbury. Verlander has looked amazing today which has really swung the deal to the point where I wont do it